Table 1. In Vitro Susceptibility of Clostridium difficile to Potential Therapeutic
Antimicrobial Agents (Data Selected from Representative Studies).
|
|
|
MIC (mg/ml) |
|
||
|
Agent |
n |
MIC50 |
MIC90 |
Range |
Reference |
|
Rifampin |
55 |
< 0.001 |
0.002 |
<0.001-0.002 |
Bacon 1991 (8) |
|
Metronidazole |
50 |
0.29 |
0.6 |
0.25-1.0 |
Bannatyne 1987 (9) |
|
Ramoplanin* |
70 |
0.25 |
0.25 |
0.12-0.5 |
Biavsco 1991 (16) |
|
Tiacumicin B* 15 |
15 |
0.25 |
0.25 |
0.12-0.5 |
Swanson 1991 (126) |
|
Tiacumicin C* |
15 |
0.5 |
1.0 |
0.25-1.0 |
Swanson 1991 (126) |
|
Teicoplanin |
70 |
0.5 |
0.5 |
0.25-1.0 |
Biavsco 1991 (16) |
|
Vancomycin |
70 |
1.0 |
2.0 |
1.0-2.0 |
Biavsco 1991 (16) |
|
Tinidazole |
50 |
0.55 |
3.74 |
0.5-4.0 |
Bannatyne 1987 (9) |
|
Bacitracin |
110 |
(MIC mode = 16 mg) |
8.0-32.0 |
Young 1985 (144) |
|
|
Fusidic Acid |
20 |
(17/20 susceptible to 10 mg, disc testing) |
Burdon 1979 (24) |
||
* Investigational agents
Table 2. Randomized, Comparative Trials of Oral Therapy for Clostridium difficile Diarrhea* [Download PDF]
|
Agent |
Regimen |
Patients Studied |
Cure Rate (%) |
Time to Resolution |
Relapse Rate (%) |
References |
|
Metronidazole |
500 mg tid x 10d |
31 |
94 |
3.2 d |
16 |
Wenisch 1996 (139) |
|
|
250 mg qid x 10d |
76 |
87, 95 |
2.4 d, NS |
42 |
Teasley 1983 (128) Musher 2006 (97) |
|
Metronidazole + rifampin |
500 mg tid x 10d |
19 |
63 |
7.0d |
|
Lagrotteria 2006 (75) |
|
Vancomycin |
500 mg tid x10d |
31 |
94 |
3.1d |
15 |
Wenisch 1996 (139) |
|
|
500 mg qid x 10d |
87 |
100 |
2.6 – 3.6 d |
29 |
Teasley 1983, deLalla 1992, Dudley 1986 (35,40,128) |
|
|
125 mg qid x 7d |
21 |
86 |
4.2 d |
NS |
Young 1985 (144) |
|
|
125 mg qid x 5d |
12 |
75 |
< 5.0 d |
19 |
Mogg 1980 (93) |
|
|
125 mg qid x 10d |
80 |
91 |
2.0 d |
7 |
Louie 2006 (83) |
|
Teicoplanin |
400 mg x bid x 10d |
28 |
96 |
2.8 d |
8 |
Wenisch 1996 (139) |
|
|
100 mg bid x 10 d |
26 |
96 |
3.4 d |
28 |
deLalla 1992 (35) |
|
Fusidic acid |
500 mg tid x 10 d |
29 |
93 |
3.8 d |
28 |
Wenisch 1996 (139) |
|
Bacitracin |
20k-25k U qid x 7-10 d |
36 |
78 |
2.5-4.1 d |
23 |
Dudley 1986, Young 1985 (40, 144) |
|
Nitazoxanide |
500 mg bid x 7 d |
40 |
90 |
NS |
23 |
Musher 2006 (97) |
|
|
500 mg bid x 10 d |
36 |
89 |
NS |
10 |
Musher 2006 (97) |
|
Tolevamer |
1 gm tid x 14 + d |
72 |
67 |
4.0 d |
4.9 d |
Louie 2006 (83) |
|
|
2 gm tid x 14 + d |
70 |
83 |
2.5 d |
NS |
Louie 2006 (83) |
|
Rifaximin |
200 mg tid x 10 d |
10 |
90 |
NS |
NS |
Boero 1990 (7) |
|
Colestipol |
10 gm qid x 5 d |
14 |
36 |
< 5.0 d |
|
Mogg 1980 (93) |
|
Placebo |
-- x 5 d |
14 |
21 |
< 5.0 d |
|
Mogg 1980 (93) |
Table 3. Empirical Treatment Strategies for Patients with Multiple Recurrences of C. difficile Diarrhea
|
Strategy |
References |
|
Saccharomyces boulardii |
McFarland 1994, Surawicz 1989, Surawicz 2000 (62, 81,82) |
|
Lactobacillus GG |
Biller 1995, Gorbach 1987 (10,38) |
|
Rectal infusion of feces or a synthetic fecal bacterial flora |
8 Reports summarized by Borody 2000 (19) |
|
Oral infusion of donor stool via NG tube |
Aas (3) |
|
Administration of a non-toxigenic C. difficile strain |
Seal 1987 (119) |
|
Vancomycin and rifampin combination |
Buggy 1987 (23) |
|
Vancomycin in tapering doses/pulsed doses |
Tedesco 1985 (89, 130) |
|
Treatment with active agent followed by 2 week course of rifaximin |
Johnson, CID 2007 (in press) |
|
Intravenous gamma globulin |
Hassett 1995, Warny 1995, Leung 1991, Wilcox 2004, McPherson 2006 (59, 77, 92, 137, 140) |
|
Whole bowel irrigation |
Liacouras 1996 (80); Persky 2000 (110) |
|
No treatment with careful observation |
Gerding 1995, Bartlett 1992 (6, 36) |
Table 4. Empirical Treatment Protocol for Clostridium difficile-Infected Patients with Severe Ileus*
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Vancomycin 500 mg per rectum every 6 hA, plus
Vancomycin 500 mg via NG tube every 6 hB, plus
Metronidazole 500 mg IV every 6 h
______________________________________________________________________________________
* Reference: 67
ALiquid intravenous formulation diluted in 100 cc of normal saline: Insert #18 Foley catheter into rectum 4 to 8 inches,
fill the balloon to 30 cc, gently pull catheter down, instill vancomycin and clamp catheter for 60 minutes, deflate balloon
and remove catheter.
BLiquid intravenous formulation diluted with at least 10 cc of fluid: clamp nasogastric tube for 60 minutes after each instillation.
Table 5. Potential Future Treatment Options
|
Product |
Type |
Stage of Development |
Company |
References |
|
C. difficile vaccine |
Vaccine |
Phase I |
Acambis |
Sougioultzis |
|
Monoclonal Antibody |
Antibody |
Phase II |
Medarex |
Gorbach |
|
Nitazoxanide |
Antibiotic |
Phase III |
Romark |
Musher CID |
|
Ramoplanin |
Antibiotic |
Phase III? |
Oscient |
Freeman JAC 2005 |
|
Rifaximin |
Antibiotic |
Phase III |
Salix |
Louie March |
|
Tiacumicin b Complex (PAR-101, also known as OPT-80) |
Antibiotic |
Phase IIb |
Optimer |
Louie 2006 March, Ackerman AAC 2004 |
|
Tolevemar |
Polymer |
Phase III |
Genzyme |
Louie CID 2006 |
Figure 1: Three Hit Disease
